| Season
| Player
| School
| Position
| Class
|
| 1951–52
| Groat, DickDick Groat
| Duke
| Guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1952–53
| Selvy, FrankFrank Selvy
| Furman
| Shooting guard
| 3 !Junior
|
| 1953–54
| Selvy, FrankFrank Selvy (2)
| Furman
| Shooting guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1954–55
| Floyd, DarrellDarrell Floyd
| Furman
| Guard
| 3 !Junior
|
| 1955–56
| Floyd, DarrellDarrell Floyd (2)
| Furman
| Guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1956–57
| Hundley, RodRod Hundley
| West Virginia
| Small forward / Shooting guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1957–58
| Flora, DomDom Flora
| Washington & Lee
| Point guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1958–59
| West, JerryJerry West
| West Virginia
| Guard
| 3 !Junior
|
| 1959–60
| West, JerryJerry West (2)
| West Virginia
| Guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1960–61
| Cohen, JeffJeff Cohen
| William & Mary
| Center
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1961–62
| Thorn, RodRod Thorn
| West Virginia
| Point guard / Shooting guard
| 3 !Junior
|
| 1962–63
| Hetzel, FredFred Hetzel
| Davidson
| Center / Power forward
| 2 !Sophomore
|
| 1963–64
| Hetzel, FredFred Hetzel (2)
| Davidson
| Center / Power forward
| 3 !Junior
|
| 1964–65
| Hetzel, FredFred Hetzel (3)
| Davidson
| Center / Power forward
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1965–66
| Snyder, DickDick Snyder
| Davidson
| Shooting guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1966–67
| Moates, JohnnyJohnny Moates
| Richmond
| Guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1967–68
| Williams, RonRon Williams
| West Virginia
| Guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1968–69
| Maloy, MikeMike Maloy
| Davidson
| Center
| 3 !Junior
|
| 1969–70
| Maloy, MikeMike Maloy (2)
| Davidson
| Center
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1970–71†
| Gregory, JimJim Gregory
| East Carolina
| Center
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1970–71†
| Jasper, TomTom Jasper
| William & Mary
| Forward
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1971–72
| Hunt, RussRuss Hunt
| Furman
| Small forward / Guard
| 3 !Junior
|
| 1972–73
| Stewart, AronAron Stewart
| Richmond
| Small forward / Shooting guard
| 3 !Junior
|
| 1973–74
| Mayes, ClydeClyde Mayes
| Furman
| Power forward
| 3 !Junior
|
| 1974–75
| Mayes, ClydeClyde Mayes (2)
| Furman
| Power forward
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1975–76
| McKeever, RodneyRodney McKeever
| Citadel !The Citadel
| Point guard
| 3 !Junior
|
| 1976–77
| Carter, RonRon Carter
| VMI
| Shooting guard / Point guard
| 3 !Junior
|
| 1977–78
| Carter, RonRon Carter (2)
| VMI
| Shooting guard / Point guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1978–79
| Moore, JonathanJonathan Moore
| Furman
| Forward
| 3 !Junior
|
| 1979–80
| Moore, JonathanJonathan Moore (2)
| Furman
| Forward
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1980–81
| Payton, CharlesCharles Payton
| Appalachian State
| Center
| 2 !Sophomore
|
| 1981–82
| White, WillieWillie White
| Chattanooga
| Shooting guard
| 2 !Sophomore
|
| 1982–83
| Mikell, Troy LeeTroy Lee Mikell
| East Tennessee State
| Shooting guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1983–84
| Truesdale, ReganRegan Truesdale
| Citadel !The Citadel
| Power forward / Center
| 3 !Junior
|
| 1984–85
| Truesdale, ReganRegan Truesdale (2)
| Citadel !The Citadel
| Power forward / Center
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1985–86
| Elmore, GayGay Elmore
| VMI
| Small forward
| 3 !Junior
|
| 1986–87
| Elmore, GayGay Elmore (2)
| VMI
| Small forward
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1987–88
| Henderson, SkipSkip Henderson
| Marshall
| Shooting guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1988–89
| Taft, JohnJohn Taft
| Marshall
| Point guard
| 2 !Sophomore
|
| 1989–90†
| Jennings, KeithKeith Jennings₮
| East Tennessee State
| Point guard
| 3 !Junior
|
| 1989–90†
| Taft, JohnJohn Taft♯ (2)
| Marshall
| Point guard
| 3 !Junior
|
| 1990–91
| Jennings, KeithKeith Jennings (2)
| East Tennessee State
| Point guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1991–92†
| Boyd, TerryTerry Boyd♯
| Western Carolina
| Guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1991–92†
| Nelson, KeithKeith Nelson₮
| Chattanooga
| Point guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1992–93
| Brooks, TimTim Brooks
| Chattanooga
| Point guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1993–94†
| Copeland, ChadChad Copeland₮
| Chattanooga
| Guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1993–94†
| King, FrankieFrankie King♯
| Western Carolina
| Shooting guard / Point guard
| 3 !Junior
|
| 1994–95
| King, FrankieFrankie King (2)
| Western Carolina
| Shooting guard / Point guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1995–96
| McCollum, AnquellAnquell McCollum
| Western Carolina
| Shooting guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1996–97
| Taylor, JohnnyJohnny Taylor
| Chattanooga
| Small forward
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1997–98†
| Phillips, BobbyBobby Phillips₮
| Western Carolina
| Small forward
| 2 !Sophomore
|
| 1997–98†
| Vincent, ChuckChuck Vincent♯
| Furman
| Power forward / Center
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1998–99
| Webber, SedricSedric Webber
| College of Charleston
| Forward
| 4 !Senior
|
| 1999–00
| Patterson, TysonTyson Patterson
| Appalachian State
| Point guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 2000–01
| Lumpkin, JodyJody Lumpkin
| College of Charleston
| Center
| 4 !Senior
|
| 2001–02†
| Childress, DimecoDimeco Childress₮
| East Tennessee State
| Shooting guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 2001–02†
| Conley, JasonJason Conley♯
| VMI
| Shooting guard / Small forward
| 1 !Freshman
|
| 2002–03
| Wheless, TroyTroy Wheless
| College of Charleston
| Shooting guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 2003–04
| Wadood, ZakeeZakee Wadood
| East Tennessee State
| Small forward
| 4 !Senior
|
| 2004–05
| Winters, BrendanBrendan Winters
| Davidson
| Shooting guard
| 3 !Junior
|
| 2005–06
| Nesbitt, EltonElton Nesbitt
| Georgia Southern
| Point guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| 2006–07
| Hines, KyleKyle Hines
| UNC Greensboro
| Power forward
| 3 !Junior
|
| 2007–08
| Curry, StephenStephen Curry
| Davidson
| Shooting guard / Point guard
| 2 !Sophomore
|
| 2008–09
| Curry, StephenStephen Curry (2)
| Davidson
| Shooting guard / Point guard
| 3 !Junior
|
| 2009–10†
| Dahlman, NoahNoah Dahlman₮
| Wofford
| Forward
| 3 !Junior
|
| 2009–10†
| Sims, DonaldDonald Sims♯
| Appalachian State
| Point guard
| 3 !Junior
|
| 2010–11
| Goudelock, AndrewAndrew Goudelock
| College of Charleston
| Shooting guard / Point guard
| 4 !Senior
|
| School (year joined)
| Winners
| Years
|
| Furman (1936)
| 10
| 1952, 1953, 1954, 1955, 1956, 1972, 1974, 1975, 1979, 1980, 1998†
|
| Davidson (1936)
| 9
| 1963, 1964, 1965, 1966, 1969, 1970, 2005, 2008, 2009
|
| Chattanooga (1976)
| 5
| 1982, 1992†, 1993, 1994†, 1997
|
| East Tennessee State (1978)[a]
| 5
| 1983, 1990†, 1991, 2002†, 2004
|
| VMI (1924)[b]
| 5
| 1977, 1978, 1986, 1987, 2002†
|
| West Virginia (1950)[c]
| 5
| 1957, 1959, 1960, 1962, 1968
|
| Western Carolina (1976)
| 5
| 1992†, 1994†, 1995, 1996, 1998†
|
| College of Charleston (1998)
| 4
| 1999, 2001, 2003, 2011
|
| Appalachian State (1971)
| 3
| 1981, 2000, 2010†
|
| The Citadel (1936)
| 3
| 1976, 1984, 1985
|
| Marshall (1976)[d]
| 3
| 1988, 1989, 1990†
|
| Richmond (1936)[e]
| 2
| 1967, 1973
|
| William & Mary (1936)[f]
| 2
| 1961, 1971†
|
| Duke (1928)[g]
| 1
| 1952
|
| East Carolina (1964)[d]
| 1
| 1971†
|
| Georgia Southern (1991)
| 1
| 2006
|
| UNC Greensboro (1997)
| 1
| 2007
|
| Washington & Lee (1921)[h]
| 1
| 1958
|
| Wofford (1997)
| 1
| 2010†
|
| Elon (2003)
| 0
| —
|
| Samford (2008)
| 0
| —
|